publichouse.sg

Tools
A+ R A- wide normal
Login
  • Skip to content
publichouse.sg » Home » Categories » Top Story » Community » The story behind the fire at Toa Payoh
  • Subscribe RSS

  • HomeOverview of publichouse.sg
  • About UsOverview of publichouse.sg
  • Categoriesoverview
    • Community
    • Focus
    • Editorial
    • Music
    • Top Story
    • Football
    • Sex Matters
    • Events
    • What Others Say
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • People
    • Health
    • Environment
    • Alternative Life Stuff
    • Finance/Business
    • Entertainment
    • Foreign Desk
  • Store 
  • contactwith us
Tuesday, 29 May 2012 16:44

The story behind the fire at Toa Payoh

  • Written by  Andrew Loh
  • font size decrease font size decrease font size increase font size increase font size
  • Print
  • E-mail
  • 3 comments
Tweet
The story behind the fire at Toa Payoh

By Andrew Loh / Pictures by Ravi Philemon

“A fire broke out at Blk 52 Toa Payoh Lorong 6 on Sunday evening, the second case this week involving discarded items at a lift landing.” – Channel NewsAsia (CNA), 6 May 2012.

As it turned out, CNA was wrong. The items were not discards.

The story behind the fire is not as straightforward as the media portrayed it.

The “discarded items” mentioned by CNA belonged to 56-year old Mr Aheairy and his wife, Mdm Sharipah, 61. The couple had placed their belongings in the common space at the lift lobby because there was no room to store them in the house where they’re currently putting up – a two-room rental flat which belongs to Mr Aheairy’s daughter, at Blk 52.

Publichouse.sg visited the family, along with concerned Singaporeans Mr Ravi Philemon and his wife, and others, several weeks ago, just after the fire gutted the common space on the 8th floor where their flat is located.

Mr Aheairy has 3 children from his previous marriage. All 3 children have married and are living in their own rental flats. Mdm Sharipah, who was also previously married, has 3 children of her own as well. She has lost contact with 2 of them, while the 3rd lives on her own.

Mr Aheairy had sold his previous flat because of his divorce to his previous wife. The profit from the flat was divided between him and his former wife, leaving little profit, after paying off his commitments.

Mdm Sharipah had had a flat together with one of her daughters but they had to sell it when her daughter got married.

The couple’s only refuge was to put up with Mr Aheairy’s daughter in the rental flat at Blk 52, along with his daughter’s 4 young children, making it a total of 8 persons living in the small flat.

The fire that gutted the corridor had also destroyed all of the couple’s possessions, including important documents, their work clothes and the bicycle which Mr Aheairy used to ride to work.

How the fire started is still under investigation. Mischief cannot be ruled out. It would be unfair to insinuate that people like Mr Aheairy are actually the ones who started the fire.

In the meantime, Mr Aheairy has been appealing - to no avail - to the Housing and Development Board (HDB) for a rental flat for him and his wife. He has also approached various Members of Parliament (MP) who have tried to help him by appealing on his behalf. “I must have appealed more than 10 times,” Mr Aheairy says.

Mr Philemon had also written on Mr Aheairy’s behalf to the HDB and the Ministry for National Development (MND) on 11 May. It has been almost 3 weeks but Mr Philemon has yet to receive any replies to his letter, besides an auto-acknowledgment.

The Bishan-Toa Payoh Town Council had issued a S$150 fine to Mr Aheairy for leaving his possessions, including his bicycle, in the common area.

Mr Philemon wrote to the Town Council to seek a waiver of these fines.

He has yet to hear from them too.

Mr Aheairy says he is not seeking donations or any special treatment. He acknowledges his responsibility for keeping his possessions in the common area but he feels he didn’t really had a choice. Where else should he keep them, given that he has no place of his own, and his daughter’s flat is already full, and all his appeals for a rental flat were rejected?

Mr Aheairy used to ride his bicycle to work, until it got destroyed in the fire. He says it was cheaper for him to travel by bicycle than to use public transport. He had been working odd jobs previously but he recently managed to find full-time employment. It pays him S$1,300 a month. It is an amount with which he could service the rent of a rental flat.

Mdm Sharipah too hopes to go back to work once she has recovered from the surgery to her foot which she underwent recently.

About two weeks ago, the couple again approached their MP and are awaiting the outcome of this latest appeal.

In the meantime, they have to contend with sleeping on the floor of their daughter’s flat.

On 11 May, Mr Philemon donated some mattresses and pillows to the couple so that they do not have to sleep on the bare concrete floor.

A kind-hearted Singaporean who came to know of their plight is also donating a bicycle to Mr Aheairy, so that he can cycle to work again.

While the news report on the illegal “dumping” of bulky items on common areas, and various parties point the finger at those responsible, perhaps we should also realise that there are good reasons why some have no choice but to leave their belongings in public areas.

In a case like Mr Aheairy, who had no choice but to sell his previous HDB flat because of divorce, where is he to go, given that his children too live in small rental units and have their own families to care for?

And as his case shows, appealing to the authorities seems to be a fruitless undertaking. What then is he and his wife to do now?

The only option seems to be to rent from the open market. But with prices at such high levels, what would Mr Aheairy and his wife live on, after paying the rent?

*Special thanks to Ravi Philemon for additional reporting.

Read also: Lack of appropriate housing and space another reason for recent fires.

--------------

Join publichouse.sg on Facebook:


If you like this article, please consider a small donation to keep publichouse.sg running. Our contributors and we thank you for your generosity.



Published in Community
Social sharing
  • Add to Google Buzz
  • Add to Facebook
  • Add to Delicious
  • Digg this
  • Add to Reddit
  • Add to StumbleUpon
  • Add to MySpace
  • Add to Technorati
Andrew Loh

Andrew Loh

Andrew's passion are social and political issues. His writings have been reproduced in other publications, including the Australian Housing Journal in 2010. Andrew also writes weekly for Yahoo Singapore which nominated him as one of Singapore's most influential media persons in 2011 and cited him for having "pioneered a new form of journalism in Singapore - the kind that dared to speak truth to power."

Latest from Andrew Loh

  • MDA's censorship rules apply to readers' comments too
  • Gov't continues to be out of touch
  • Erosion of trust in public institutions not necessarily a bad thing
  • When activists cross the line
  • Cartoonist's arrest - not just about alleged sedition
More in this category: « An apology - and then the conspiracy theories Chan Chun Sing - The price of politics »

3 comments

  • Comment Link Samuel Koh Wednesday, 30 May 2012 12:15 posted by Samuel Koh

    Thank you for the most enlightening article. Its great to see what went on beyond the article, to see the human face behind the mishap.

    I have a good friend whom through unfortunate circumstances have landed up in a rental flat. Between him and his dad, the flat has been almost totally filled up, leaving precious little space for anything else. I cannot imagine how 8 people squashed in a rental flat would be like. Living in a 24 men bunk in Tekong (where we still had space to walk around and interact) must seem like a bungalow compared to that.

    It is a fallacious argument that we should not build rental flats just because one does not want a "squatter" settlement of people living off the government. Only the minority do just that, the rest try their hardest to rise above poverty. Providing them an affordable place to stay, if only for 2 years (rental flats are on a 2 year lease) is a proven stepping stone for those in poverty to move socially upwards.

  • Comment Link siao liao Tuesday, 29 May 2012 23:43 posted by siao liao

    yes, since the gahmen said $1k enuff to BUY your own flat, poor mr aheairy shld be allowed to do juz that.

    i suggest publichouse do periodic follow up on this case. wld be great to see if pap's claim is real or comes attached with a string of conditions.

    wld be to pap's credit if mr aheairy can really own his own place, and make a living, with his level of salary. if not, shame on the gahmen, for making housing so unaffordable to ordinary citizens.

  • Comment Link kitsura Tuesday, 29 May 2012 22:22 posted by kitsura

    Didn't DPM Tharman say that $1k is able to afford a flat? Since he is earning $1.3k I doubt he will get rental since he can afford a HDB flat.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.

Learn more about our commenting policy(clicking on this link will open up another window)

back to top

Recent Articles

  • Remembering Qu Yan - people-first leadershp
    Remembering Qu Yan - people-first leadershp By Dr  Wong Wee Nam “Those who are wise do…
    1 comment Read more...
  • Singapore once had a free press
    Singapore once had a free press By Elaine Ee It wasn’t always this way. The media…
    2 comments Read more...
Subscribe to this RSS feed

Our Sponsors

Categories

  • Focus (14)
  • Hindsight (0)
  • Columnists (0)
  • Editorials (29)
  • Music (23)
  • Sex Matters (26)
  • Odd Man !n (6)
  • Discourse with Dr. Tilde (0)
  • Events (33)
  • Public TV (0)
  • Picture House (0)
  • What Others Say (38)
  • Top Story (16)
  • Politics (191)
  • Economy (6)
  • People (35)
  • Health (4)
  • Environment (6)
  • Alternative Life Stuff (9)
  • Community (396)
  • Finance/Business (11)
  • Entertainment (7)
  • Foreign Desk (8)
  • Subscribe RSS
publichouse.sg © 2011. All rights reserved.

  • Forgot your password?
  • Forgot your username?